A redesign is a chance to improve the way customers understand and use your website. It is also a moment when valuable search traffic can be lost if the old site is replaced without a plan. Before choosing colours or a new layout, identify what already earns visits and enquiries.
1. Decide why the site needs changing
Is the problem dated branding, difficult editing, slow loading, poor mobile experience or weak enquiries? Write down the business outcome. “A modern website” is a design preference; “more qualified quote requests from our core services” is a useful objective.
2. Take a baseline
Record current organic traffic, enquiries, conversion rates and important rankings. In Search Console, identify pages with impressions and clicks, along with the queries that bring visitors. In analytics, see which pages lead to contact or booking. This gives you a reference after launch.
3. Inventory your existing pages
Make a list of live URLs and decide whether each page is kept, rewritten, combined or retired. Do not remove a page solely because it looks old; it might answer a useful question or attract a specific audience. Note the target page for every retired URL.
4. Plan redirects and internal links
If a URL changes, use a relevant permanent redirect to the best replacement. Avoid redirecting every old page to the homepage. Update internal links, menus, buttons, PDFs and campaign landing pages so users reach the right destination directly.
5. Keep the content that earns trust
Retain useful service detail, examples, testimonials, FAQs and location information. Improve weak copy, but do not replace specific answers with generic marketing statements. Customers need to understand what you do, who it is for and why they should contact you.
6. Design the enquiry journey
Map what happens from the first visit to a real conversation. Make key pages clear on mobile, keep forms proportionate to the enquiry, provide a phone option where appropriate and confirm that submissions reach the right person. Test the full journey, not just the appearance of the form.
7. Check the technical foundations
Before launch, verify mobile layouts, performance, accessibility basics, image sizes and alt text, titles and descriptions, canonicals, structured data where appropriate, sitemap, indexability and analytics. Ensure staging pages are not indexed and the live site is not accidentally blocked.
8. Test before and after launch
Use a launch checklist with named responsibilities. Test important pages, forms, booking and payment paths. After launch, crawl for broken links and watch Search Console for indexing issues. Compare traffic and conversions to the baseline over several weeks rather than reacting to a single day.
When should you rebuild rather than refresh?
If the existing site has sound structure and content, targeted improvements may be enough. A rebuild makes more sense when the platform, design system or content architecture prevents the business from growing. The decision should follow an audit, not an assumption.
Jigsaw can review the current site, protect what works and build a clearer route to enquiries. Explore our website design approach or ask us to review your redesign plan.
Frequently asked questions
Will my rankings drop during a redesign?
Short-term movement is possible, but careful URL mapping, preservation of valuable content, redirects and post-launch monitoring reduce avoidable risk. A redesign is not a reason to erase established pages.
Should every old page be redirected?
Not automatically. Redirect a retired URL to a genuinely relevant replacement. A page with no equivalent may need a different decision; sending every URL to the homepage is rarely useful.
When should I check Search Console?
Review it before the rebuild to establish a baseline, immediately after launch for crawl and indexing issues, and regularly in the following weeks as Google processes changes.
Who should own the launch checklist?
A named person should coordinate design, content, technical checks, analytics and sign-off. Clear ownership prevents a form, redirect or important page from being overlooked.
Common launch mistakes
One common mistake is publishing polished pages while forgetting the practical details: contact forms, email delivery, cookie preferences, booking confirmations and mobile navigation. Another is relying on a list of redirects without checking that each destination actually works. A third is comparing a new site’s first week with a previous month without considering seasonality or tracking changes.
Build a short test plan around the pages and actions that generate business. Have somebody unfamiliar with the project try to find a service, understand the offer and send an enquiry. Their confusion is useful evidence to resolve before launch.
Make the next step work for your business
Jigsaw can help you turn a clearer website and practical systems into better enquiries.